The Blanket

The Blanket - A Journal of Protest & Dissent

From IRA to OCA?

Radical Unionist political commentator Dr John Coulter maintains the only way the republican movement can disband the Provisionals without causing a major split is to form an Old Comrades’ Association similar to the Royal British Legion.

Dr John Coulter • 11 November 2004

The Provisional IRA is in a real dilemma – how does it take its arsenals and terror structure out of Irish politics, whilst at the same time not spark mass defections to the Continuity and Real IRA dissidents?

There is an old maxim – of you can’t beat them, join them. In hard political terms, the IRA needs to copy its arch rivals, the British Army, and form an Old Comrades’ Association to get around the thorny problem of those nasty D words – decommissioning and disbanding.

West Belfast MP Gerry Adams really landed himself in hot water with the republican hardline activists in East Tyrone, South Derry and South Armagh with a recent ‘way forward’ statement in which he envisaged a republican movement without the physical force element.

Adams was really trying to spike the rival Ian Paisley-led Democratic Unionist Party’s artillery with his perception the Provisionals might have to disband to make way for political progress.

His remarks exploring a scenario where the IRA might no longer exist have been totally misinterpreted in Northern Ireland Provisional heartlands as: ‘Thanks for the last generation of armed struggle, now bog off and let us politicians work out a deal!’

However, the high-wire balancing act the Sinn Fein leadership has to perform is to radically sideline the IRA, but at the same time convince the Provisionals’ ruling Army Council that ‘they really haven’t gone away’ – an observation made famous by Adams at a post-ceasefire republican rally.

Many grassroots republican activists must be privately questioning what they devoted almost 30 years of armed struggle to. Was all that suffering by republican prisoners and families simply to run the education and health departments of Northern Ireland?

During the time of the brief power-sharing Executive in 2002, Sinn Fein held the ministries of health and education.

The problem for republicans is that if they are to finally defeat the constitutional nationalist SDLP at the ballot box, they must capture and hold not just the traditional Catholic working class areas, but the electorally lucrative and growing Catholic middle class in the North.

ith a Westminster election looming within the next 18 months, Sinn Fein is poised to capture the SDLP’s three remaining Commons seats of Foyle, South Down, and Newry and Armagh. Sinn Fein is also on the brink of its biggest electoral achievement in the Republic of Ireland since the post-Great War General Election when it took the majority of Irish seats.

If Sinn Fein can mirror its European and local government successes in the South of Ireland in next year’s expected Irish General Election for Dail seats, there is a strong possibility the party could become a leading contender for coalition government with the largest Southern party, Fianna Fail … but only if it cleans up the Provos!

The Provisional IRA needs restructuring. It needs to deliver the double blow of convincing unionism it no longer exists as a terrorist organisation, whilst at the same time providing a network of communications for republican hardliners.

There is already talk of mainstream republicanism commissioning service medals for those IRA activists who took part in the Troubles, in much the same way as the British Army issues campaign or service medals to its soldiers.

Urging republicans to copy the British Army model of forming regimental associations may seem the talks of traitors. It could also be interpreted as insulting by organisations such as the Royal British Legion, whose primary aim is to maintain contact between former soldiers of legitimate army units.

This is a poignant time for British Army war veterans and serving personnel as they remember fallen and wounded comrades from past wars, especially those of the 20th century.

An Irish Republican Association would allow the Provisionals to maintain both contact and discipline amongst its active service units. The last thing which the IRA Army Council wants is activists with itchy trigger fingers deciding to sells themselves as ‘hired guns’ to either the dissident republican movement or Catholic-based criminal gangs.

But what would be so wrong in nationalist terms of revamping the IRA into the Irish Republican Association? After all, when the part-time police force dominated by Protestants, the B Specials, disbanded in 1970, thousands of unionists flocked to swell the ranks of the Ulster Special Constabulary Association.

And in the 1990s, after the merger of the British Army’s Protestant-dominated Ulster Defence Regiment with the Royal Irish Rangers to form the Royal Irish Regiment, an UDR Association quickly emerged. Similar associations have also been formed within the police to mark the Royal Ulster Constabulary and RUC Reserve.

The Provisionals would also be copying the famous International Brigade which fought the fascist dictator Franco during the Spanish Civil War. Whilst that conflict ended generations ago, the sacrifice of the members of that Brigade is honoured through old comrades’ groups.

The Provisionals – because they are based in Western Europe - need to distance themselves from the modern-day Middle Eastern Islamic fundamentalist terrorists who use suicide bombers and mass slaughter techniques to further their so-called causes.

They also need to distance themselves from republican purists who adopt a Viet Cong stance of shooting at the last British helicopter as it ferries the final batch of troops out of RAF Aldergrove. To isolate the dissident republican movement, the mainstream family needs to convince the Real and Continuity IRA that this is the Ireland of the third millennium – not the Irish equivalent of mid 1970s South Vietnam.

The republican movement also needs to urgently convince middle class Northern Ireland it is no longer a threat to society. If Sinn Fein is to be viewed as a truly democratic organisation by Protestants in the same way the African National Congress became trusted by whites in South Africa, then the IRA has got to permanently go away.

If it does not follow this path, the republican movement will become nothing more than the Irish version of African Marxist dictator Robert Mugabe’s veterans movement in Zimbabwe. It is effectively the Patriotic Front terrorism under another banner.

But for mainstream republicanism to totally disband the armed wing without replacing it with some form of disciplined structure will only play into the hands of republican dissidents.

The republican leadership of Adams and Mid Ulster MP Martin McGuinness need to make a bold statement – not about the disbanding of the IRA, but to restructure republicanism’s physical force volunteers into an Irish Republican Association.

Such a brave move will allow unionists to enter a power-sharing executive at Stormont, and force loyalist terror groups to return the serve and form themselves into Shankill Road-style drinking clubs.







Index: Current Articles + Latest News and Views + Book Reviews + Letters + Archives

The Blanket - A Journal of Protest & Dissent



All censorships exist to prevent any one from challenging current conceptions and existing institutions. All progress is initiated by challenging current conceptions, and executed by supplanting existing institutions. Consequently the first condition of progress is the removal of censorships.
- George Bernard Shaw

Index: Current Articles

11 November 2004

Other Articles From This Issue:

Palestine Greater than Arafat
Sam Bahour

Gerry Adams: Man of War and Man of Peace?
Anthony McIntyre

From IRA to OCA?
Dr. John Coulter

The Orange Order: Go Forward by Going Back
Rev. Brian Kennaway

Choosing to Ignore the Facts: Not the Fault of the Left
Tara LaFreniere

Onward Christian soldiers
Tyrone Gottlieb

7 November 2004

How We Progressives Helped Elect G.W. Bush
Fred A. Wilcox

No Escape from the Anthill
Seaghán Ó Murchú

Talking With... Áine Gribbon

Meeting Hugh Orde
Anthony McIntyre

A Woman's Right to Choose
Mick Hall

A Single Palestine
Peter Urban

Turkey Day
Brian Mór



The Blanket




Latest News & Views
Index: Current Articles
Book Reviews
The Blanket Magazine Winter 2002
Republican Voices